Scott’s on Fifth, located at 141 Fifth Ave. in Indialantic, is widely regarded as one of Brevard County’s finest dining destinations. Blending classic fine dining with inventive twists, Chef Scott Earick personally curates and prepares each meal, earning loyal fans and rave reviews with his attention to both quality and creativity.
Atmosphere & Experience
The intimate restaurant features a colorful, Hollywood-glam interior, white linen tablecloths, and artistic decor that create an inviting yet upscale ambiance. Diners are greeted by friendly, professional staff, and the exemplary service consistently receives high praise.
Chef’s Touch
Scott Earick—a former TV chef and actor—runs a true one-man kitchen, shopping for the freshest local produce and seafood. He is known to develop the menu personally, changing it regularly based on what’s best in-season, while keeping a few beloved staples such as crab bisque, filet mignon, and Penne alla Vodka. Every dish at Scott’s on Fifth is crafted with precision and presented elegantly, from his signature “Shrimpcargot” to creative seafood and steak dishes.
Menu Highlights
Expect to find classics like:
-
Crab Bisque: A signature soup, thick, rich, and perfectly seasoned.
-
Onion-Crusted Fresh Catch, Lamb, Filet Mignon, Penne alla Vodka with baby shrimp.
-
Decadent desserts such as Coconut Cream, Upside-Down Key Lime Pie, and Chocolate Slab, known for their perfect balance and rich flavors.
The menu is small but ever-changing, focusing on the freshest ingredients and homemade touches. There’s a full bar, an excellent wine list, and nightly specials.
The Verdict
Scott’s on Fifth is celebrated for its steadfast commitment to excellence—no shortcuts in the kitchen and innovative, classic cuisine done right. Critics and guests alike consider it an essential stop for discerning diners seeking both simple elegance and culinary adventure. Reservations are recommended, and the restaurant is open Tuesday through Sunday, 5:30 pm to close. For a dining experience that elevates local cuisine to new heights, Scott’s on Fifth stands out as a must-visit on the Space Coast.
Contact: (321) 729-9779 | scottsonfifth.com
The ambiance and dining experience at Scotts On Fifth
Scott’s on Fifth exudes an intimate, upscale, and distinctly Hollywood-glam ambiance. The interior sparkles with colorful art, dazzling chandeliers, white linen tablecloths, and eclectic decor—creating a cozy yet sophisticated setting perfect for a romantic dinner or special celebration.
Dining Experience
-
Guests are greeted with warm hospitality and attentive service from both Chef Scott Earick and his well-trained staff. The open kitchen allows diners to witness Chef Scott personally crafting each dish, adding a sense of exclusivity and authenticity to the experience.
-
The atmosphere is lively yet relaxed, with an elegant air that encourages conversation and appreciation of the artistry behind each meal.
-
Many diners describe the environment as “welcoming” and “unique,” noting the personal attention given to every guest and the vibrant personality of the restaurant.
Food Presentation & Quality
-
Dishes are served with artistic flair, combining classic and creative flavors using only the freshest locally sourced ingredients.
-
Menu selections—a blend of beloved classics and nightly specials—are prepared and curated by Chef Scott himself, who tailors each night’s offerings based on seasonal market finds.
-
The experience is elevated by decadent desserts and a curated wine list, further enhancing each meal.
Overall, dining at Scott’s on Fifth is not just a meal—it’s an immersive journey of taste and style. Guests leave remembering not only the outstanding food but also the warm, elegant setting and the feeling of being truly cared for
